The Research of Paper Influence Based on Citation Context - A Case Study of the Nobel Prize Winner's Paper
نویسندگان
چکیده
Citation context was used to measure the influence of highly cited papers. The themes of citation context were analyzed with bibliometrics methods. The citation context was classified into three categories as positive, negative and neutral. And the neutral citations were also classified into three sub categories, related work in background or introduction, theoretical foundation, and experimental foundation. The citation contexts of a highly cited paper of O’Keefe were extracted as the experiment data set. The results showed that the co-occurrence method was very useful for describing the themes of the citation contexts. The citation contexts of the selected paper were divided into five themes. The classification of citation contexts could provide more information about how and why a paper was highly cited. There was no negative citation in this experiment, and more than 10% citation contexts were positive citation. About 50% of the neutral citations were belonging to related work in background or introduction. The detailed influence of the target paper was also illustrated in our research.
منابع مشابه
The 1982 Nobel Prize in Chemistry goes to Structural Biologist Aaron Klug
The 1982 Nobel prize in chemistry was awarded to Aaron Klug, Medical Research Council’s (MRC) Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Cambridge, England. The purpose of this essay is to examine the impact of his research, with particular emphasis on citation analysis. We have examined each crop of annual Nobel prizes awarded since 1979.1-0 Beginning with the 1982 awards, however, we have modified our ...
متن کاملA Simple Index for the High-Citation Tail of Citation Distribution to Quantify Research Performance in Countries and Institutions
BACKGROUND Conventional scientometric predictors of research performance such as the number of papers, citations, and papers in the top 1% of highly cited papers cannot be validated in terms of the number of Nobel Prize achievements across countries and institutions. The purpose of this paper is to find a bibliometric indicator that correlates with the number of Nobel Prize achievements. METH...
متن کاملThe 1983 Nobel Prizes. Part 1. Physics and Chemistry Awards go to Chandrasekhar, Fowler and Taube
We have examined each group of annual Nobel Prize winners since 1979. Beginning with the 1982 awards, I we included data from the research fronts we identify each year for Science Citation Index” (SCP’ ). Briefly, a research front is a group of current papers that cite a cluster of “core” papers identified by co-citation clustering. These procedures have been described previously.2 By systemati...
متن کاملHubble ’ s Nobel Prize D . S . L .
Astronomy is not in the list of natural sciences aimed at by the Nobel awards. In spite of that, there were, throughout the 1930s until the early 1950s, effective moves by important scientists to distinguish Hubble with the Prize. A short report on these attempts is made as well as speculation on what would be the citation for the prize in view of the broad range of Hubble's scientific achievem...
متن کاملDo Nobel Prize Winners Write Citation Classics?
In the recently concluded series on the 1,000 articles most cited in the Science Citation Inde# (.SCP ), 1961 to 1982, I drew attention to the many Nobel laureates who were authors of one or more of these highly cited papers. 1 It was no surprise that 14 percent of the 1,000 papers were written by Nobel Prize winners, since we knew that as a group they are heavily cited. In 1965 Irv Sher, ISP’s...
متن کامل